As a fan of Gillen’s work, I’ve been looking for an opportunity to properly try his Thor run – not least because of his recently-established reputation as one of Marvel’s top writers of assorted Gods – but having not read a word of Straczynski’s run, found his first arc a little too difficult to get into. Tying more directly into Siege, however – and requiring much less in the way of background context, to the extent that even if you didn’t know your Norse Mythology you’d still get a good sense of most characters’ usual purposes – the first issue of his second (and final) arc is a much more accessible and appealing prospect.
And what impresses, really, is that for someone who’s still written relatively little for Marvel (although it’s a volume that’s growing by the week), Gillen works with such confidence and sure-footed-ness. He slots comfortably into Marvel’s current setup as if he’s been doing it for ages (although it can’t hurt that he has existing ties with contemporaries of such importance as Fraction), and on a job that was so significantly redefined by a previous incumbent, it’s no mean feat to pick up the characters and setting and work with them so naturally. His trademark wit, though, is evident throughout – most notably whenever the Asgardians have cause to mention Volstagg (“only a serious threat to roasts”, apparently), although it’s also no mean feat to turn in a laugh-out-loud reference to Twibbons (not to mention using Youtube as a plot device) in a book so heavily based around characters and customs around a millennium old. Meanwhile, his aforementioned and distinctive flair for Godly dialogue continues, with the speech patterns of the assorted Asgardians flowing in a way that just feels right without ever lapsing into “TO BE CONTINUETHED”s and the like.
Plotting is strong, too, with the decision to centre the story around Volstagg a wise one – in Gillen’s hands, he’s a truly delightful character (if a slightly cliched likeable bumbler), and you feel genuinely sorry for him as he tries to deal with the mess he’s been unwittingly thrown into. Notably, too, a potential major slipup in Siege‘s own plot is averted – just how can you surprise attack Asgard when Heimdal’s around? – and I don’t know if this is part of the overall plan or if it’s simply something that Gillen’s sought to address, but it’s deftly handled, with a cunning bit of scheming given to Loki. The countdown to “Ragnarok” (another neat juxtaposition of a very modern and film-esque storytelling device with a word so resonantly classical) also turns out to be a neat feint, even though it subsequently leads to an appearance of someone/thing that we’d all probably rather forget even exists.
All in all, though, this is strong work – not even hampered that much by employing two different artists, each quite different in style – as Billy Tan sticks to Volstagg’s scenes (and imbues him with appealing character expression), while Rich Elson gives a lusher, more classical feel to the Asgard pages. Speaking as someone who’s never had a huge interest in Thor as a title (I get my Norse mythology from Neil Gaiman, mostly), this is a surprisingly and immediately engaging read. And while I’m sure Matt Fraction’s got plenty of big ideas lined up for when he takes over, there is a slight disappointment that Gillen’s only around for such a short time.

Given Daredevil’s heavily self-contained nature over the last ten-plus years, it’s strange to see Marvel effectively put the first issue of the new direction in a one-shot. Then again, given that the time is about right to move the character away from the Bendis/Brubaker version, perhaps it’s not so strange at all. Daredevil’s new position as Leader of the Hand is, in part, related to the events of Secret Invasion and Dark Reign, so it seems to make sense to expose the status quo to new readers in the series-of-one-shots, The List.
Even though “the search for a new sorcerer supreme” isn’t quite the draw that someone at Marvel seems to think it is, New Avengers is still an enjoyable title, largely because it allows Bendis to do what Bendis does best. Which is, to say: talking. Lots of it. For the second issue in a row, a fair chunk of this issue revolves around super-heroes standing still and chatting about what’s going on. If you don’t truck with that, then fair enough – but go read Mighty Avengers instead.
New Avengers is a title under the fairly real threat of losing its “top billing” status at the moment. A price hike combined with the end of the title’s long-running lynchpin, Secret Invasion, has left the book feeling a little superfluous to requirements, especially now that Dark Avengers is, for now at least, taking over the series’ position as Marvel’s “event” title. Meanwhile, regular artist Billy Tan, despite improving in leaps and bounds over the last year, is still far below the required level for “New Avengers” talent.
Someone should talk to Bendis about how he approaches New Avengers. As fellow-reviewer Seb recently said to me, they should really just re-title this series “New Luke Cage” and have done with it. Cage is, and always has been, the most well-developed character in the book, and whenever Bendis gets a chance to really dig into him, the series noticeably improves as a result.